My Way or the Buy-Way? Should you start your business from scratch or buy a franchise?

Cary Cheung wakes up at 4:30 a.m. every morning to run a business that requires him to pay a fee. He doesn’t own it outright, and it doesn’t even bear his name. And yet he couldn’t be happier.

That’s because Cheung is a franchise owner of Doc Popcorn, a maker of flavored popcorn that uses a variety of organic and all-natural ingredients. In fact, Cheung abandoned his career as an assistant vice-president at WaMu Investments to become Doc Popcorn’s very first franchisee in November 2009. And just a few weeks ago, Cheung and his wife, Judy, opened their second Doc Popcorn location in California.

Pull-Quote-Tall.pngThe Cheungs aren’t alone. According to the International Franchise Association, approximately 4 percent of all businesses in the United States are franchisee-worked. And the consultancy Franchise Marketing Systems says that franchising is a business model that generates more than $1 trillion in U.S. sales annually across more than 70 industries. Franchised businesses ran 767,483 establishments in the United States through 2008, including establishments owned by both franchisees and franchisors.

But while running a franchise business can be both professionally attractive and personally satisfying, not everyone is cut out for the task. Just ask Amy Bennett, owner of The Greene Grape, a Brooklyn, New York-based seller of fine food and wine. The choice was obvious to Bennett: “Part of opening my own business rather than a franchise was for it to be a creative outlet for me. I wanted something I could contribute to meaningfully.” Add that desire for creativity to the many negatives associated with franchising, such as royalty fees, restrictive licenses, meddlesome franchising authorities, and a lack of ownership, and it is easy to see why many are dissuaded from signing up to become a party to a franchise.

For many others, of course, those negatives are more than outweighed by the many benefits of running a business associated with an established brand and backed by the marketing muscle and support of a large corporation. So how do you know if you’re best suited to run a franchise or if you should strike out on your own? Answering these five questions can get you a step closer to the right answer.

1. How much legwork are you willing to do?

“When you invest in a franchise, you’re getting the brand name of the franchisor, the operating system, a proven track record, not to mention ongoing support, education and training,” says Brian Miller, president of The Entrepreneur’s Source, a business ownership consultancy in Connecticut. “If you started out running your own business, however, you really wouldn’t have anybody to rely on.”

That kind of pre-existing structure was precisely why the Cheungs opted to run a franchise. “My parents owned their own restaurant so I saw the struggles they had starting off and all those lessons they had to learn,” he says. “The attraction of a franchise is the system is created for you.”

“There are very few people who are true entrepreneurs and who can really go out and make a business their own,” says Miller. “But there are a lot of people who have that passion and fire in their belly and know that they want to take control of their own destiny but need a little bit of help.”

2. What are you willing to invest financially?

Launching your own business often requires little to no capital, especially if you start small. But many popular franchises demand lots of upfront capital and collateral—sometimes up to millions of dollars—from a prospective franchisee before offering a contract. These “working capital reserves,” as they’re called, are often required by franchisors so that they will feel comfortable that a franchisee can stay in business until he or she reaches the financial break-even point.

In the case of Cheung, he invested between $100,000 and $150,000 to open his first store, including upfront franchise fees. “That was a main reason why we chose Doc Popcorn—the low entry point.” Every other franchise he looked at was going to cost from $200,000 to $250,000 to start, he says.

Still, some franchises are willing to lend a helping financial hand. “My wife and I funded the store on our own, but I know that Doc Popcorn has third-party connections to help with funding,” says Cheung.

To learn more, check out our previous article on franchise startup costs.
3. Can you back someone else’s product?

While there’s definitely something to be said for creating your own business, many entrepreneurs are proud to peddle a franchise’s products. “The only reason we signed with Doc Popcorn is because of the product and what it represents,” says Cheung. “Of course, trying to make money is always a goal for all business owners but you have to believe in the product.”

For Bennett, however, launching The Greene Grape was an opportunity to express herself and act on her vision of a perfect wine shop. “At the time I opened my first wine store, there wasn’t really a franchise that focused on handcrafted, affordable wine,” she says. “My twist on a regular wine store was part of the creative process.”

4. How much say would you like in the business?

“The advantages to running your own business are mostly in creative control,” says Bennett. “I can market the way I want, my store can have a personality that reflects who we are. This means a lot more work, of course, but at the end of the day I can step back and be proud of how the store is presented.”

That’s not to suggest that franchisees don’t have any input. Rather, Miller explains, “As you become successful in a franchise system, there are opportunities for you to work collaboratively and to develop new products and services.”

5. How long can you wait to break even?

According to Miller, “the support given by a franchise in the beginning in terms of brand recognition means that you might have a quicker start in terms of sales. Educating the consumer for a new business definitely takes more time. Depending on how a franchise agreement is structured, that could mean breaking even for the franchisee earlier.”

Still, if the substantial franchise buy-in requirements are too steep, taking the franchise route (and its more desirable, early break-even point) may not be a realistic option for many budding entrepreneurs. Instead, they may have no other option but to launch on their own, either diving into entrepreneurship full-time and striving for a quick rise in profits or running a side or part-time venture for a longer period of time, until the business proves it can stand on its own.

Comments (49)

  1. UGG Classic Argyle Knit 5879

    Hello there, You have done a great job. I will definitely digg it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they’ll be benefited from this web site.

    Reply
  2. UGG Classic Stripe Cable Knit 5822

    My brother suggested I might like this blog. He was totally right. This put up truly made my day. You cann’t believe simply how a lot time I had spent for this information! Thanks!

    Reply
  3. Rona Nussbaum

    Goede informatie, hier kan ik zeker wat mee bedankt!

    Reply
  4. Burberry Outlet UK

    I definitely take pleasure in looking through on this web website , it holds fantastic articles .

    Reply
  5. HarrisonDalton

    Thank you for a great post.

    Reply
  6. Louis Vuitton Bags For Cheap

    You made some first rate points there. I appeared on the internet for the difficulty and found most men and women will go along with together along with your site.

    Reply
  7. Hermes Sale

    Just thought I might leave a comment to say how considerably I enjoyed reading this read. Quality blog!

    Reply
  8. Designer Handbags Sale

    We can make further discussion via yahoo messenger. Your post is great, I had read and stand by within your site for a week, I use this for my research. We can make another conclusion for this valuable post.

    Reply
  9. Hermes Sale

    Normally I don’t read post on blogs, but I wish to say that this write-up rather forced me to try and do it! Your writing style has been amazed me. Thanks, especially nice post.

    Reply
  10. Louis Vuitton Handbags Cheap

    Thanks for any other fantastic post. Where else could anybody get that type of information and facts in such an ideal approach of writing? I’ve a presentation next week, and I’m on the search for such info.

    Reply
  11. Designer Handbags Sale

    Everyone loves it,Outstanding article.We’re put this into work with 1 these days.We appreciate you sharing this.To Your Success!

    Reply
  12. Hermes Replica

    Awesome weblog, it’s just like a game for me! It’s so infomative and usefull, thanks a good deal! If you post more of this great stuff, I’ll visit your blog again!

    Reply
  13. LinusBarr

    Very good! Although all of our transmitters can do that anyway.

    Reply
  14. Hermes Replica

    I believe that I would surely go loony not having this internet internet site. It is the 1st matter I take a look at prior to going to work and the pretty last factor I carry out previous to heading off for the nighttime.

    Reply
  15. Hermes Replica

    I like the way your blog looks, way cool.

    Reply
  16. Chase Online Login

    I saw this really greatgood post today….

    Reply
  17. Cheap Designer Handbags

    Surprisingly illuminating numerous thanks, It looks like your current visitors might possibly want way more well written articles like this carry on the excellent content.

    Reply
  18. Balenciaga Bag Sale

    Generally I do not post on sites, however , I would like to state that this post really obligated me to take action! really nice post

    Reply
    1. Liliek

      Dorothy Posted on i like the names dohtory, kendall, simone, taylor, anna caroline, elizabelle, miranda and la laine, makensie and shawnmy top 5 are: Dorothy, simone, la laine, kendall and makenzie

      Reply
    2. uccapsmcrn

      mBXHGn nrxdahnizhwa

      Reply
  19. Louis Vuitton Bags Outlet

    Incredibly helpful appreciate it, I believe your current visitors will most likely want a fantastic deal more posts of this nature maintain up the very good content.

    Reply
  20. Cheap Louis Vuitton

    Pretty interesting information !Perfect just what I was looking for!

    Reply
  21. Designer Replica Bags

    Particularly challenging bless you, I believe your readers would most most likely want significantly more articles similar to this keep up the decent hard work.

    Reply
  22. Discount Louis Vuitton Purses

    I wonder what is the lack of Google method that do not rank this type of informative sites in top of the list. Generally the top sites are full of garbage.

    Reply
  23. Louis Vuitton wallets

    Yeah bookmaking this wasn’t a high risk decision outstanding post! .

    Reply
  24. Replica Chanel Bags

    I definitely delight in visiting your web-site! your great method to see points is what keeps me interested. Thanks so significantly!!!!

    Reply
  25. Replica Louis Vuitton Hats

    Thanks for this post. I don’t know a large number of links to forums but my friends seem to be able to spend a lot of time on them that’s for sure.

    Reply
  26. Replica Gucci Bags

    Astonishingly illuminating many thanks, There’s no doubt that your trusty visitors will likely want a whole lot more articles along these lines keep up the wonderful effort.

    Reply
  27. Fake Louis Vuitton Belt

    i cant beleive i stumbled onto your post..thanks so a lot!!! i am going to have to sign up

    Reply
  28. Replica Handbags Louis Vuitton

    Your blogposts are always so impressive and especially inspiring. Thank you a great deal for finding the time to help encourage others!

    Reply
  29. Replica Handbags Louis Vuitton

    Here we go again?- I’m spending an highly lengthy time reading these blogs. Oh Well! It was worth it.

    Reply
  30. LV Handbags Outlet

    Thank you for this interesting write-up, i’ll bookmark this page

    Reply
  31. Louis Vuitton Handbags Sale

    Hi there, I’m just establishing my 1st internet internet site, looking around and figuring out what is required. This blog stuck out straight away. I’m psyched about this, and adore the feel of your page. Are you able to let me know what “theme” you are using?

    Reply
  32. Louis Vuitton Replica Glasses

    I like the way your blog looks, way cool.

    Reply
  33. Discount Designer Handbags

    When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove me from that service? Thanks!

    Reply
  34. LV Handbags On Sale

    This website online is known as a stroll-through for the entire info you needed about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse here, and also you’ll undoubtedly discover it.

    Reply
  35. Burberry Outlet

    Especially amazing post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to mention that I’ve truly enjoyed browsing your weblog posts. In any case I will be subscribing for your rss feed and I hope you write again incredibly soon!

    Reply
  36. Louis Vuitton Belt

    Hi; Wonderful post for me. Your post has excellent quality. I wish to has valuable posts like yours in my weblog. How do you obtain these posts?

    Reply
  37. Louis Vuitton Belt For Sale

    Hello! It’s my first time to visit your webpage. And i love it. Enjoy your theme and the quality of every content to have it here. Fresh and new ideas and thoughts. Thanks for sharing your quality of time and effort for making this.

    Reply
  38. Cheap Prada Bags

    Not long ago i identified your internet internet site and also have been reading along. I thought I’d leave my initial remark. Good weblog. I will maintain visiting this internet site especially frequently.

    Reply
  39. Louis Vuitton Belt

    Outstandingly good cheers, I reckon your visitors may well well want significantly more posts similar to this carry on the very good content.

    Reply
  40. Louis Vuitton Handbags Sale

    Valuable details and exceptional design you got here! I would like to thank you for sharing your thoughts and time into the stuff you post!! Thumbs up!

    Reply
  41. Gucci Outlet

    I just book marked your blog on Digg and StumbleUpon. I enjoy reading your commentaries.

    Reply
  42. Louis Vuitton Bags Sale

    What theme are you using on your site ? I honestly like the layout. Countless thanks for the post.

    Reply
  43. Hermes Replica

    Hello, I used to be researching the internet and I revealed your web webpage. Maintain up the outstanding work.

    Reply
  44. Fake Louis Vuitton Belt

    Wow! This can be 1 particular of one of the most valuable blogs We have ever arrive across on this topic.

    Reply
  45. Hermes Sale

    Nice blog. Located it using Bing. Think I’ll be back to see what else you’ve blogged about.

    Reply
  46. Replica Louis Vuitton Hats

    What exactly questions that marilyn and i include a terrific college, considering meant for your ex boyfriend rational predatory instincts means which will deciding on the enterprise, will be currently becoming depicted, is the exact. She argues which in most cases persons don’t have any option to apprehend this really is connected with positive important points

    Reply
  47. Tibet travel

    I don??t normally touch upon blogs.. But nice post! I merely bookmarked your online site

    Reply

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.